Menu
Call
Contact
Blog

Buy-Sell Agreements for Business Partners in North Carolina

buy-sell-agreement-nc

A buy-sell agreement is a contract between business owners that decides what happens to an owner’s share if that owner dies, becomes disabled, divorces, retires, or wants out. It sets who can buy the share, how the price is calculated, and where the money comes from.

Most North Carolina business partners don’t have one. Many find out why they need one after a partner’s health scare, a divorce filing, or a call from a partner’s widow asking about “her half” of the company.

Without a buy-sell agreement, North Carolina’s default rules and your partner’s estate plan decide who owns that share. You may not like the answer.

What Happens Without a Buy-Sell Agreement in North Carolina?

When a business owner dies without a buy-sell agreement, their ownership interest becomes part of their estate. It passes under their will. If there’s no will, it passes to their heirs under North Carolina’s intestate succession laws.

What that means for you depends on how your business is set up.

If you own an LLC: Under the North Carolina Limited Liability Company Act (N.C.G.S. Chapter 57D), a member generally stops being a member at death unless the operating agreement says otherwise. The estate usually keeps the economic rights, meaning a share of profits and distributions, but not a vote in management.

That leaves your partner’s estate owning a slice of your profits with no duty to help run the company. You have no obligation to buy them out. They have no obligation to sell. Both sides are stuck.

If you own a corporation: Shares pass to the heirs like any other asset. Unless there are transfer restrictions in place, your partner’s spouse or children can become full shareholders with voting rights.

Either way, you could end up in business with people you never chose.

The 5 D’s: Events a Buy-Sell Agreement Should Cover

Death gets the most attention. It’s not the only risk. A strong buy-sell agreement addresses every major way an owner can leave the business.

1. Death. The agreement requires or allows the surviving owners or the company to buy the deceased owner’s share from the estate. The family receives fair value. You keep control.

2. Disability. What if your partner survives but can’t work for a year? Or ever? The agreement should define “disability” clearly and set a waiting period before a buyout kicks in.

3. Divorce. North Carolina divides marital property through equitable distribution. An owner’s business interest can be part of that. Without a buy-sell agreement, a partner’s ex-spouse could end up holding a piece of your company or forcing a valuation fight in court.

4. Departure. Retirement, a new career, or getting fired. The agreement should set the terms for a voluntary exit and whether the price changes depending on how the owner leaves.

5. Disagreement. When 50/50 partners deadlock, nothing moves. Many agreements include a “shotgun” clause or other mechanism that forces a resolution, so one owner can buy out the other.

A buy-sell agreement can also cover bankruptcy, loss of a professional license, and what happens if an owner tries to sell to an outsider.

Types of Buy-Sell Agreements

The structure you choose affects taxes, cash flow, and who ends up owning what.

Type Who Buys the Share Best Fit Watch Out For
Cross-purchase agreement The remaining owners buy personally Businesses with two or three owners Gets complicated as the number of owners grows
Entity redemption (stock redemption) The company buys the share back Businesses with several owners Can increase the company’s value for estate tax purposes
Hybrid (“wait-and-see”) Owners get the first option, then the company Owners who want flexibility Requires careful drafting so it doesn’t stall

The Supreme Court Case Every Business Owner Should Know About

In 2024, the U.S. Supreme Court decided Connelly v. United States. Two brothers owned a building supply company. Their buy-sell agreement required the company to buy out whichever brother died first, using life insurance the company owned.

When one brother died, the IRS counted the insurance money as part of the company’s value. The company’s obligation to use that money for the buyout didn’t offset it. The deceased brother’s estate owed more federal estate tax than the family expected.

The federal estate tax exemption is $15 million per person in 2026, so most small businesses won’t feel this directly. But if you own a valuable company, real estate, and life insurance, your total estate may be larger than you think. If your current agreement uses company-owned life insurance to fund a redemption, it’s worth having it reviewed.

How to Set a Fair Price

The price is where most buy-sell disputes start. There are three common approaches:

Fixed price. The owners agree on a number and write it down. It’s simple. The problem is that most owners never update it. A price set in 2015 won’t reflect what your company is worth today.

Formula. The price is tied to a calculation, like a multiple of earnings or book value. It updates automatically, but a formula that made sense for a young company may not fit a mature one.

Appraisal. An independent business appraiser determines fair market value when the buyout is triggered. It’s the most accurate approach. It also takes time and can lead to competing appraisals if the agreement doesn’t spell out the process.

Many agreements combine these. For example, the owners sign an agreed value every year, and an appraisal kicks in if they miss an update.

How to Fund a Buy-Sell Agreement

A buyout price means nothing if no one can pay it.

Most buy-sell agreements tied to death are funded with life insurance. Each owner (or the company) holds a policy on the other owners. When an owner dies, the insurance proceeds buy the share from the estate. The family gets paid quickly. The business doesn’t drain its cash.

For disability and retirement, agreements often use installment payments over several years, sometimes secured by a promissory note. Disability buyout insurance is another option.

The key is making sure the funding matches the agreement. A policy that’s too small, owned by the wrong party, or allowed to lapse can leave the whole plan unfunded. Your attorney can make sure the agreement and the funding are working together.

Where the Buy-Sell Agreement Lives

A buy-sell agreement doesn’t have to be a separate document. For an LLC, buy-sell terms are often built directly into the operating agreement. For a corporation, they may appear in a shareholders’ agreement. North Carolina law allows corporations to restrict how shares are transferred when those restrictions are properly documented under N.C.G.S. § 55-6-27.

What matters most is consistency. If your operating agreement says one thing and a separate buy-sell agreement says another, you’ve created a lawsuit waiting to happen.

Your Buy-Sell Agreement and Your Estate Plan Must Match

This is the piece many business owners miss.

Your buy-sell agreement decides who buys your share and for how much. Your estate plan decides what happens to the money your family receives.

If your will leaves “my interest in the company” to your son, but your buy-sell agreement requires the estate to sell that interest to your partner, your son gets the sale proceeds, not the company. That may be exactly what you want. It just needs to be intentional.

Your spouse should also understand the plan. A surviving spouse who expected to step into the business may be surprised to learn the agreement requires a sale.

A buy-sell agreement is one piece of a larger business succession plan. The two should be drafted with each other in mind.

Common Buy-Sell Agreement Mistakes

  • Using an online template. Generic forms don’t reflect North Carolina law, your business structure, or your family situation.
  • Never updating the price. A stale valuation can shortchange a family or bankrupt the buyer.
  • Leaving “disability” undefined. Vague language invites a fight when the stakes are highest.
  • Letting insurance lapse. An unfunded agreement is a promise no one can keep.
  • Ignoring the estate plan. The agreement and each owner’s will or trust should work together.
  • Waiting for a crisis. Partners negotiate fairly when everyone is healthy. After a death or a falling-out, they don’t.

Protect Your Business Before You Need To

The best time to sign a buy-sell agreement is when nothing is wrong. Everyone is healthy. Everyone is getting along. Nobody knows who will be the buyer and who will be the seller, so everyone negotiates fairly.

At Johnson Legal, PLLC, Shane T. Johnson draws on years of experience in business and transactions to help Wilmington business owners plan for what comes next. We draft and review buy-sell agreements, operating agreements, and business formation documents, and we make sure they line up with your personal estate plan.

Contact us online to schedule a consultation.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can an LLC have a buy-sell agreement?

Yes. In North Carolina, LLC buy-sell terms are commonly written into the operating agreement. Members can also sign a separate buy-sell agreement, as long as it’s consistent with the operating agreement.

Can I write my own buy-sell agreement?

You can, but it’s risky. A buy-sell agreement has to address valuation, funding, tax treatment, triggering events, and how it fits with each owner’s estate plan. A gap in any of those areas can surface at the worst possible moment.

What are the disadvantages of a buy-sell agreement?

A buy-sell agreement limits each owner’s ability to sell to anyone they choose, and funding it usually requires ongoing insurance premiums. It also needs periodic review so the price and terms stay current. For most co-owned businesses, those costs are far smaller than the cost of having no agreement at all.

What is the best way to fund a buy-sell agreement?

Life insurance is the most common way to fund a buyout at death. Disability and retirement buyouts are often funded through installment payments or disability buyout insurance. The right approach depends on the number of owners, their ages and health, and the value of the business.

What is a cross-purchase agreement?

A cross-purchase agreement is a type of buy-sell agreement where the remaining owners personally buy the departing owner’s share, rather than the company buying it back. It works best for businesses with a small number of owners.

How often should a buy-sell agreement be updated?

Review it at least every few years, and any time the business changes significantly. Add a new owner, take on major debt, or see a big jump in value, and it’s time for a fresh look.


Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal or tax advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every business and family is different. Consult a licensed North Carolina attorney about your specific circumstances.

Author Bio

Shane T. Johnson is the CEO and Managing Partner of Johnson Legal, an estate planning and business law firm in Wilmington, NC. With years of experience in estate and business law, he has zealously represented clients in various legal matters, including small business formation and purchasing, estate planning, probate, domestic violence, and other legal cases.

Shane received his Juris Doctor from the University of Wyoming and is a member of the North Carolina Bar Association. He has received numerous accolades for his work, including being named among the Best Probate Lawyers in Wilmington by Expertise.com.

LinkedIn | State Bar Association | Avvo | Google

Serving Wilmington, North Carolina
And Beyond